Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-05-13T15:44:54.667Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"9b492674-6906-480f-abf4-7dde81173705","new_score":23,"page_slug":"aster","prev_score":38,"reason":"The review found 42 claims across the page, with 29 confirmed and a reviewer-computed disputed_pct of 11.9%, placing this squarely in the revise band. The core risk allegations — the DeFiLlama wash trading delisting, extreme 1001x leverage, pseudonymous team, Binance-dependent USDF architecture, and extreme token concentration — are all confirmed by credible sources. However, three specific errors drive the upper-band penalty: (1) claim_findings[31] is formally disputed by a Tier 1 source — the page incorrectly states no audit firm names or report links were publicly identifiable, when Aster's documentation at docs.asterdex.com/overview/audit-reports names Salus Security, PeckShield, and Halborn and provides file links; (2) claim_findings[14] is marked stale — the page describes Aster Chain as a planned addition targeting Q1 2026, when the mainnet launched March 17, 2026, making this section materially outdated; (3) claim_findings[37] is partially_supported with inconsistency — the page attributes ~28% open interest market share to Hyperliquid in early 2026, but the cited KuCoin source states Hyperliquid held over 70% of open interest by March 2026. The market rank figure (#54 stated vs #44 on CoinMarketCap) and peak TVL claim ($1.48B stated vs up to $2.21B per other sources) are additional inaccuracies requiring correction. No high-severity coverage gaps indicate fabricated claims; the gaps suggest expansion and update, consistent with a revise verdict.","score_delta":-15,"sequence_num":2,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}