Skip to main content
AVOID.NET
← Covenant AI9 decisions on this page

Audit log

Every state-changing event for Covenant AI: moderation decisions on community submissions, plus corrections and updates from the news pipeline. URL-based decisions are designed to carry three independent witnesses — the original source, an Internet Archive snapshot, and a Solana memo signed by our publicly-disclosed publisher key. Archive coverage is still being backfilled, so each decision below reports its own snapshot status rather than assuming one exists.

  1. #1publishby system:backfill
    2026-09-30 12:13:39Z
    Score: ? → ? (no score change)
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 451,961,404
    sig
    5VcTBoT3EvCi…vaPuvWuiexplorer ↗
    hash
    3NqeKh1cvBPi…fvx6bH6Fsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (14331 B) ▸
    {"actor":"system:backfill","investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","kind":"publish","page_slug":"covenant-ai","published_at":"2026-09-30T12:13:39.534Z","sequence_num":1,"snapshot":{"content_type":"investigation","entity_name":"Covenant AI","sections":[{"content":"Covenant AI, led by founder Sam Dare, operated as a subnet developer on Bittensor, a decentralized machine-learning network built on Substrate/Polkadot technology and denominated in the TAO token. Covenant AI ran three subnets — Templar (Subnet 3), Basilica (Subnet 39), and Grail (Subnet 81) — and was known for developing Covenant-72B, described in coverage as one of the largest decentralized large language model pre-training efforts on the network. Prior to its April 2026 exit, Covenant AI was widely regarded as one of Bittensor's flagship contributors and a prominent public advocate for the project.","heading":"Background: Covenant AI's Role in Bittensor","severity":"low","sources":[{"credibility":2,"name":"'It is decentralization theatre': Covenant AI exits Bittensor, TAO drops 15% - The Block","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.theblock.co/post/396959/covenant-ai-exits-bittensor-tao"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Covenant AI Announces Exit From Bittensor Project After Calling It Decentralization \"Theatre\" - Crowdfund Insider","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.crowdfundinsider.com/2026/04/272467-covenant-ai-announces-exit-from-bittensor-project-after-calling-it-decentralization-theatre/"}]},{"content":"In April 2026, Sam Dare announced Covenant AI's exit from Bittensor, alleging that the network's governance was 'decentralization theatre.' Dare alleged that co-founder Jacob Steeves 'maintains effective control over the triumvirate, resists any meaningful transfer of authority, and deploys changes unilaterally whenever he chooses, without process and without consensus.' Dare further stated that 'the entire premise of Bittensor ... is that no single entity controls it. That promise is a lie,' and said Covenant AI could not 'raise capital, attract talent, or ask our community to commit resources on top of a foundation that one person can undermine at will.' Covenant AI's specific allegations against Steeves included suspending emissions to Covenant's subnets, revoking the team's community-moderation access, unilaterally deprecating subnet infrastructure, and using strategically timed token sales as alleged 'punitive leverage.' Bittensor's own governance documentation describes a transitional structure in which a 'Triumvirate' of Opentensor Foundation employees holds root permissions alongside a senate rather than a fully open governance model, a structure Covenant AI's allegations directly targeted. These allegations are disputed by Bittensor's co-founder and have not been independently substantiated beyond the public statements of both parties.","heading":"Exit and Allegations Against Bittensor Leadership","severity":"high","sources":[{"credibility":2,"name":"Covenant AI exits Bittensor over 'decentralization theatre,' TAO drops 18% - Cointelegraph via TradingView","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.tradingview.com/news/cointelegraph:8eac14495094b:0-covenant-ai-exits-bittensor-over-decentralization-theatre-tao-drops-18/"},{"credibility":2,"name":"'It is decentralization theatre': Covenant AI exits Bittensor, TAO drops 15% - The Block","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.theblock.co/post/396959/covenant-ai-exits-bittensor-tao"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Covenant AI accuses Bittensor of 'centralized control with decentralized branding' amid exit - AMBCrypto","type":"news_article","url":"https://ambcrypto.com/covenant-ai-accuses-bittensor-of-centralized-control-with-decentralized-branding-amid-exit/"}]},{"content":"As Covenant AI's exit unfolded, on-chain and market observers reported that the team sold approximately 37,000 TAO worth of alpha tokens from its subnets — reported at roughly $10-12 million depending on the exact price at time of sale — around the same time it publicly announced its departure. Coverage stated Covenant 'sold 37,000 TAO and left Templar SN3 on April 10.' This concentrated sale, occurring simultaneously with public criticism of Bittensor's leadership, led to widespread accusations within the Bittensor community that Covenant AI's exit constituted a rug pull against holders and stakers who had backed its subnets. Community commentary noted an alleged contradiction between Dare's previously positive public statements about Bittensor's founder and the timing of the token sale, which some observers characterized as coordinated rather than principled. Bittensor co-founder Jacob Steeves, in a public statement, characterized the episode as an attempt by Dare to 'cause maximum pain to both him personally and to the Bittensor protocol,' and issued what was described as 'a direct and sincere apology to those who lost money, lost faith, or had the financial rug pulled from underneath them.' These rug-pull characterizations originate primarily from Bittensor-aligned community commentary and market analysis rather than from a regulatory or judicial finding, and should be treated as alleged pending further independent verification. Covenant AI has not, in available reporting, offered a detailed on-the-record rebuttal to the rug-pull characterization itself, distinct from its broader governance grievances.","heading":"Alleged Token Sale and 'Rug Pull' Accusations Against Covenant AI","severity":"critical","sources":[{"credibility":2,"name":"Bittensor (TAO) Drops 5% Amid Covenant AI Exit and Profit-Taking - CoinMarketCap","type":"news_article","url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/6a08b1b937da1e3365a7b849/"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Bittensor Drops 27% as Covenant AI Exit Sparks Governance Crisis - CoinMarketCap","type":"news_article","url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/69dd25af14cadf4840f348f2/"},{"credibility":3,"name":"The Rug Pull of Covenant AI - TAO Media","type":"community_report","url":"https://www.tao.media/the-rug-pull-of-covenant-ai/"},{"credibility":3,"name":"Bittensor Co-Founder Jacob Steeves Responds to Covenant AI - SimplyTao","type":"community_report","url":"https://simplytao.ai/blog/jacob-steeves-const-response-covenant-ai"}]},{"content":"The dispute and associated token sales coincided with a sharp decline in the TAO token. Reporting varied on the exact magnitude: some outlets reported a drop of roughly 15-18% within hours of the announcement, while others tracking a wider 72-hour window reported a cumulative decline of up to 25-27%, with TAO falling from a high near $338-340 to a low around $248-285. Market capitalization losses were estimated between $650 million and $900 million, and outlets reported between $9 million and $11 million in liquidated long positions. Trading volume reportedly spiked to $1.7-1.8 billion over 24 hours, two to three times the prior average. TAO had risen 90-140% over the preceding six weeks before the crash, and some analysts noted the token was technically overextended near resistance before the Covenant AI news broke, meaning the dispute may have amplified a correction already in progress rather than being its sole cause.","heading":"Market Impact","severity":"high","sources":[{"credibility":2,"name":"Bittensor Drops 27% as Covenant AI Exit Sparks Governance Crisis - CoinMarketCap","type":"news_article","url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/69dd25af14cadf4840f348f2/"},{"credibility":2,"name":"'It is decentralization theatre': Covenant AI exits Bittensor, TAO drops 15% - The Block","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.theblock.co/post/396959/covenant-ai-exits-bittensor-tao"},{"credibility":3,"name":"TAO (Bittensor) 24-hour volatility reaches 36.5%: CovenantAI exit triggers plunge from $339.7 high to $248.8 low - Bitget News","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.bitget.com/news/detail/12560605357436"}]},{"content":"Jacob Steeves publicly disputed Covenant AI's characterization of the dispute, stating he did not hold 'any privilege beyond what normal TAO holders have' and that he could not unilaterally suspend subnet emissions. Steeves said any tokens he personally sold from the three subnets in question were sold because those subnets 'were not running and were on near 100% burn code.' He nonetheless apologized to those affected by the price crash and credited Covenant AI's technical work, stating the project had shown that 'open-source, permissionless networks can genuinely compete with centralized, billion-dollar, fiat-funded AI labs.' In response to the incident, Bittensor said it would accelerate a governance change, variously described as 'Locked Stake' and 'Conviction,' intended to require subnet owners to lock tokens for defined periods and make large exits visible on-chain before they can generate significant sell pressure. Coverage indicated the 'Conviction' upgrade shipped to Bittensor's mainnet the following month. Bittensor also stated the three affected subnets (3, 39, and 81) remained open-source and that community members were organizing to continue the underlying work independent of Covenant AI.","heading":"Bittensor's Response and Governance Changes","severity":"medium","sources":[{"credibility":3,"name":"Bittensor Co-Founder Jacob Steeves Responds to Covenant AI - SimplyTao","type":"community_report","url":"https://simplytao.ai/blog/jacob-steeves-const-response-covenant-ai"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Bittensor (TAO) Drops 5% Amid Covenant AI Exit and Profit-Taking - CoinMarketCap","type":"news_article","url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/6a08b1b937da1e3365a7b849/"}]}],"sources_used":[{"credibility":2,"name":"Covenant AI exits Bittensor over 'decentralization theatre,' TAO drops 18% - Cointelegraph via TradingView","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.tradingview.com/news/cointelegraph:8eac14495094b:0-covenant-ai-exits-bittensor-over-decentralization-theatre-tao-drops-18/"},{"credibility":2,"name":"'It is decentralization theatre': Covenant AI exits Bittensor, TAO drops 15% - The Block","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.theblock.co/post/396959/covenant-ai-exits-bittensor-tao"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Bittensor Drops 27% as Covenant AI Exit Sparks Governance Crisis - CoinMarketCap","type":"news_article","url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/69dd25af14cadf4840f348f2/"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Bittensor (TAO) Drops 5% Amid Covenant AI Exit and Profit-Taking - CoinMarketCap","type":"news_article","url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/6a08b1b937da1e3365a7b849/"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Covenant AI accuses Bittensor of 'centralized control with decentralized branding' amid exit - AMBCrypto","type":"news_article","url":"https://ambcrypto.com/covenant-ai-accuses-bittensor-of-centralized-control-with-decentralized-branding-amid-exit/"},{"credibility":2,"name":"Covenant AI Announces Exit From Bittensor Project After Calling It Decentralization \"Theatre\" - Crowdfund Insider","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.crowdfundinsider.com/2026/04/272467-covenant-ai-announces-exit-from-bittensor-project-after-calling-it-decentralization-theatre/"},{"credibility":3,"name":"TAO (Bittensor) 24-hour volatility reaches 36.5%: CovenantAI exit triggers plunge from $339.7 high to $248.8 low - Bitget News","type":"news_article","url":"https://www.bitget.com/news/detail/12560605357436"},{"credibility":3,"name":"The Rug Pull of Covenant AI - TAO Media","type":"community_report","url":"https://www.tao.media/the-rug-pull-of-covenant-ai/"},{"credibility":3,"name":"Bittensor Co-Founder Jacob Steeves Responds to Covenant AI - SimplyTao","type":"community_report","url":"https://simplytao.ai/blog/jacob-steeves-const-response-covenant-ai"}],"summary":"Covenant AI was one of the Bittensor network's most prominent subnet operators, running Templar (SN3), Basilica (SN39), and Grail (SN81), and developing the Covenant-72B decentralized language model. In April 2026, founder Sam Dare publicly exited Bittensor, accusing co-founder Jacob Steeves of exercising unilateral, centralized control behind a facade of decentralized governance — a claim Steeves denied. The dispute coincided with Covenant AI selling roughly 37,000 TAO (an estimated $10-12 million) of alpha tokens while withdrawing, which triggered a sharp TAO price crash, tens of millions in liquidations, and widespread accusations within the Bittensor community that Covenant AI's own exit amounted to a rug pull.","timeline":[{"date":"2026-04","event":"Covenant AI founder Sam Dare publicly announces the team's exit from Bittensor, calling the network's governance 'decentralization theatre' and accusing co-founder Jacob Steeves of unilateral control over the project.","source":"The Block","source_url":"https://www.theblock.co/post/396959/covenant-ai-exits-bittensor-tao"},{"date":"2026-04","date_evidence":"sold 37,000 TAO and left Templar SN3 on April 10,","date_original":"2026-04-10","event":"Covenant AI sells approximately 37,000 TAO worth of alpha tokens and departs Templar (Subnet 3), triggering accusations that the exit amounted to a rug pull against subnet stakers.","source":"CoinMarketCap","source_url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/6a08b1b937da1e3365a7b849/"},{"date":"2026-04","event":"TAO price falls sharply amid the dispute, with reported declines ranging from roughly 15-18% within hours to a cumulative 25-27% over 72 hours, alongside $9-11 million in liquidations.","source":"CoinMarketCap / The Block","source_url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/69dd25af14cadf4840f348f2/"},{"date":"2026-04","date_original":"2026-04-11","event":"Jacob Steeves responds publicly, denying centralized control of Bittensor, apologizing to those who lost money in the crash, and announcing a 'Locked Stake' proposal to prevent future sudden subnet-owner exits.","source":"SimplyTao","source_url":"https://simplytao.ai/blog/jacob-steeves-const-response-covenant-ai"},{"date":"2026-05","date_evidence":"Conviction upgrade shipped to mainnet May 13","date_original":"2026-05-13","event":"Bittensor's 'Conviction' governance upgrade, developed in response to the Covenant AI incident, ships to mainnet.","source":"CoinMarketCap","source_url":"https://coinmarketcap.com/top-stories/6a08b1b937da1e3365a7b849/"}]},"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 3fcfd726-0a83-4ab3-952d-b8a2d61abbb6
  2. #2reviewby reviewerreviewer
    2026-10-27 10:54:05Z
    Score: 38 → 38 (no score change)
    The core narrative (April 2026 exit, decentralization theatre accusation, Steeves denial, TAO decline of roughly 15-27%, Conviction rollout) is supported by The Block, Blockonomi and others. Errors: the exit announcement is dated April 10 in the body and in a timeline entry, but The Block dates it April 9, and the timeline lists it twice. The 'greed and malice' quote, the 38-of-41 audit, the Binance destination and the Teutonic 80B model were not found in the sources checked. The token sale rests on a single opinion source (TAO Media), yet is presented as undisputed. Several claims were not fetched, so the review is a partial spot-check.
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 462,044,053
    sig
    xqWtnkqbB6Pm…c7vkG7cVexplorer ↗
    hash
    7K1psWBBrFk7…3WBHMA3csha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1496 B) ▸
    {"actor":"reviewer","artifact_identity":"ce139e1ae5b9f20f56537d88c4a5efb3","decided_at":"2026-10-27T10:54:05.551Z","decision":"review","disputed_pct":0.4615,"findings_hash":"4Hix2HJn38tcdbddZLibzMgD3EKa4UciRrYGp4s23zNB","investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"8800307026131ea9d5da939d32b9a1f1884b2b84a5de33c8e87931d36f38d0f8","new_score":38,"omissions":{"material":0,"total":1},"page_content_hash":"1d69a463fea61c25de75438960157c2d26be39d229a240052d63bd0ca2039a22","page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":38,"reason":"The core narrative (April 2026 exit, decentralization theatre accusation, Steeves denial, TAO decline of roughly 15-27%, Conviction rollout) is supported by The Block, Blockonomi and others. Errors: the exit announcement is dated April 10 in the body and in a timeline entry, but The Block dates it April 9, and the timeline lists it twice. The 'greed and malice' quote, the 38-of-41 audit, the Binance destination and the Teutonic 80B model were not found in the sources checked. The token sale rests on a single opinion source (TAO Media), yet is presented as undisputed. Several claims were not fetched, so the review is a partial spot-check.","reviewer_def_hash":"bc11388ce4bc4deea1b064fea362663ae06e3f4f687f99604769044d6ffba770","score_delta":0,"sequence_num":2,"subject_status":"rebranded","subject_status_contradicts_page":false,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 03fd35d8-ab06-4ea7-8269-af951fba43c2
  3. #3review reviseby judgejudge
    2026-10-27 10:54:05Z
    Score: 38 → 26 (-12)
    Of 13 claims checked, 1 was disputed and 5 could not be verified (6 of 13, about 46%), none because a source blocked the reviewer. The exit announcement is dated April 10 on the page, but The Block dates it April 9 (claim_findings[0]), and the timeline lists it twice (claim_findings[1]). The 'greed and malice' quote, the 38-of-41 governance audit and the Teutonic 80B training run were not found in the cited sources (claim_findings[2], [5], [8]). The 37,000 TAO sale is presented as undisputed but rests on one opinion source (claim_findings[6], [7]). The core narrative of the exit, the Steeves denial and the TAO decline is confirmed, and the reviewer's confidence was moderate (0.6) on a partial spot-check, so the penalty sits in the middle of the band. No material omission or status contradiction was reported.
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 462,044,059
    sig
    5cHK5m7wrkof…NYAXnzrXexplorer ↗
    hash
    CeZYAsXPgd5Z…uSNUhfXVsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1575 B) ▸
    {"actor":"judge","artifact_identity":"ce139e1ae5b9f20f56537d88c4a5efb3","band_override":null,"decided_at":"2026-10-27T10:54:05.551Z","decision":"review_revise","delist_requested":false,"disputed_pct":0.4615,"investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"8800307026131ea9d5da939d32b9a1f1884b2b84a5de33c8e87931d36f38d0f8","new_score":26,"page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":38,"reason":"Of 13 claims checked, 1 was disputed and 5 could not be verified (6 of 13, about 46%), none because a source blocked the reviewer. The exit announcement is dated April 10 on the page, but The Block dates it April 9 (claim_findings[0]), and the timeline lists it twice (claim_findings[1]). The 'greed and malice' quote, the 38-of-41 governance audit and the Teutonic 80B training run were not found in the cited sources (claim_findings[2], [5], [8]). The 37,000 TAO sale is presented as undisputed but rests on one opinion source (claim_findings[6], [7]). The core narrative of the exit, the Steeves denial and the TAO decline is confirmed, and the reviewer's confidence was moderate (0.6) on a partial spot-check, so the penalty sits in the middle of the band. No material omission or status contradiction was reported.","reviewer_def_hash":"bc11388ce4bc4deea1b064fea362663ae06e3f4f687f99604769044d6ffba770","score_delta":-12,"score_limit":{"applied":-12,"limited":true,"proposed":-20,"rule":"limited_no_second_opinion","second":null},"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 62ef12d0-e87e-4d01-831b-9181ee492e51
  4. #4reviewby reviewerreviewer
    2026-11-02 08:40:24Z
    Score: 26 → 26 (no score change)
    The core narrative (April 9 exit, Dare's accusations, Steeves's denials, TAO price move) matches The Block and Cointelegraph, and the page hedges appropriately on weak claims. One real error: Steeves's 'not even sure what this accusation refers to' quote is misattributed and does not appear in the cited sources. The 37,000 TAO sale and Teutonic rename rest on thin sourcing, and the Cointelegraph source contradicts the sale-timing description. Several claims were not fully checked.
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 464,431,586
    sig
    2L35wZ4WKTL2…FEdq3So3explorer ↗
    hash
    ACcZJMAGaCuF…8xr3cKAAsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1373 B) ▸
    {"actor":"reviewer","artifact_identity":"0eea1625bb7b98ac2b154a2a58fc4874","blocked_count":1,"decided_at":"2026-11-02T08:40:24.301Z","decision":"review","disputed_pct":0.2727,"findings_hash":"4zj8QYQB2Edo4AhHyYsjvS3knzK4CwHhCfqUtj7pA83p","investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"8800307026131ea9d5da939d32b9a1f1884b2b84a5de33c8e87931d36f38d0f8","new_score":26,"omissions":{"material":0,"total":1},"page_content_hash":"b48732fd20811385fb11c526895fac9941793c2e74602ed614d8064edd3ed76e","page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":26,"reason":"The core narrative (April 9 exit, Dare's accusations, Steeves's denials, TAO price move) matches The Block and Cointelegraph, and the page hedges appropriately on weak claims. One real error: Steeves's 'not even sure what this accusation refers to' quote is misattributed and does not appear in the cited sources. The 37,000 TAO sale and Teutonic rename rest on thin sourcing, and the Cointelegraph source contradicts the sale-timing description. Several claims were not fully checked.","reviewer_def_hash":"bc11388ce4bc4deea1b064fea362663ae06e3f4f687f99604769044d6ffba770","score_delta":0,"scored_claims":11,"sequence_num":4,"subject_status":"rebranded","subject_status_contradicts_page":false,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 80ec0667-0d52-4266-b444-314a417b693f
  5. #5review reviseby judgejudge
    2026-11-02 08:40:24Z
    Score: 26 → 28 (+2)
    The core narrative (the April 9, 2026 exit, Dare's accusations, Steeves's denials and the TAO price move) matches The Block and Cointelegraph. One statement is wrong: claim_findings[3] attributes Steeves's 'not even sure what this accusation refers to' quote to the Tao Papers allegation, but the cited Block article shows he said something similar about a different claim. Two further claims were not corroborated (claim_findings[8] and [9]), giving 3 of 11 scored claims (about 27%) disputed or unverifiable. The sourcing for the 37,000 TAO sale and the Teutonic rename is thin (claim_findings[2] and [4]), and the review lists a high-priority gap for primary sources. Because of this, and because the reviewer's confidence was moderate, the page gets a modest penalty and a correction request, not a harsher band.
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 464,431,592
    sig
    3BNofMjwC2uM…8nVUZC3Sexplorer ↗
    hash
    B5XAaiiUaG2g…fJRsDxKUsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1564 B) ▸
    {"actor":"judge","artifact_identity":"0eea1625bb7b98ac2b154a2a58fc4874","band_override":null,"blocked_count":1,"decided_at":"2026-11-02T08:40:24.301Z","decision":"review_revise","delist_requested":false,"disputed_pct":0.2727,"investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"8800307026131ea9d5da939d32b9a1f1884b2b84a5de33c8e87931d36f38d0f8","new_score":28,"page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":26,"reason":"The core narrative (the April 9, 2026 exit, Dare's accusations, Steeves's denials and the TAO price move) matches The Block and Cointelegraph. One statement is wrong: claim_findings[3] attributes Steeves's 'not even sure what this accusation refers to' quote to the Tao Papers allegation, but the cited Block article shows he said something similar about a different claim. Two further claims were not corroborated (claim_findings[8] and [9]), giving 3 of 11 scored claims (about 27%) disputed or unverifiable. The sourcing for the 37,000 TAO sale and the Teutonic rename is thin (claim_findings[2] and [4]), and the review lists a high-priority gap for primary sources. Because of this, and because the reviewer's confidence was moderate, the page gets a modest penalty and a correction request, not a harsher band.","replaces_fact_checks":{"score_before_fact_checks":38,"undone":1},"reviewer_def_hash":"bc11388ce4bc4deea1b064fea362663ae06e3f4f687f99604769044d6ffba770","score_delta":2,"scored_claims":11,"sequence_num":5,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 3a3ae287-c8ff-455d-a19c-aa5861d6b09a
  6. #6reviewby reviewerreviewer
    2026-11-03 22:08:44Z
    Score: 28 → 28 (no score change)
    The core narrative (April 9, 2026 exit, 'decentralization theatre', roughly 15% TAO drop, contested token-sale allegation) holds against The Block and TaoDaily, and the page labels weak claims as unverified. Two defects were found: the claim that Steeves 'apologized' is not supported by the fetched sources, and 'lock staking' mislabels his 'lock-based subnet ownership' proposal. The summary also overstates Steeves's denial. Only part of the sourcing was checked.
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 465,061,242
    sig
    2gwsXtZX4RhF…GAkc5Rhhexplorer ↗
    hash
    8Tk4DHDX2rBc…AUMz1T1Zsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1317 B) ▸
    {"actor":"reviewer","artifact_identity":"ed76c53982a392ee82e54313eca6d42d","decided_at":"2026-11-03T22:08:44.585Z","decision":"review","disputed_pct":0.4444,"findings_hash":"F4GdMuB3pCdUp7Q9wm8RfrVkq4BrNzhy7a4hqvn3fHEQ","investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"750934ecb48272224909b7430fab271676d391380fbc821acbe7ee7e4cac2fa3","new_score":28,"omissions":{"material":0,"total":1},"page_content_hash":"b2026fb0aec55e58ba25ca3cbf837b9349a93dfedb69310c9cb8192152867aa7","page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":28,"reason":"The core narrative (April 9, 2026 exit, 'decentralization theatre', roughly 15% TAO drop, contested token-sale allegation) holds against The Block and TaoDaily, and the page labels weak claims as unverified. Two defects were found: the claim that Steeves 'apologized' is not supported by the fetched sources, and 'lock staking' mislabels his 'lock-based subnet ownership' proposal. The summary also overstates Steeves's denial. Only part of the sourcing was checked.","reviewer_def_hash":"3839668b232611e5b26db72079d64745f8e57e919b8a379e79b44ba4a52c845b","score_delta":0,"sequence_num":6,"subject_status":"operating","subject_status_contradicts_page":false,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 9afd509f-adb8-4ce6-8352-b0a3fa7255d6
  7. #7review reviseby judgejudge
    2026-11-03 22:08:44Z
    Score: 28 → 23 (-5)
    Of 9 claim findings, 2 were disputed (claim_findings[1] and [2]: the page says Steeves apologized and proposed 'lock staking', but the sources report no apology and call the proposal 'lock-based subnet ownership') and 2 could not be verified (claim_findings[7] and [8], not checked in the review's time budget), giving 44%, which falls in the significant-issues band. The core account holds up: the April 9, 2026 exit, the 'decentralization theatre' quote and the roughly 15% TAO drop are confirmed by Tier 2 sources. The penalty is set at the mild end of the band because the disputed items are wording errors rather than errors in the core allegations, the unverifiable items are already labelled provisional on the page, and the reviewer's confidence was moderate (0.6). No shutdown, exploit or sanction was found, and the one omission (Covenant AI's post-exit plans) is minor. The high-priority gap is the lack of primary sources (Dare's statement, on-chain records for the alleged 37,000 TAO sale).
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 465,061,256
    sig
    5dbPHxkU3rWb…fZyBXmCAexplorer ↗
    hash
    6EV374v117xG…ZdBQuavHsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1820 B) ▸
    {"actor":"judge","artifact_identity":"ed76c53982a392ee82e54313eca6d42d","band_override":null,"decided_at":"2026-11-03T22:08:44.585Z","decision":"review_revise","delist_requested":false,"disputed_pct":0.4444,"investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"750934ecb48272224909b7430fab271676d391380fbc821acbe7ee7e4cac2fa3","new_score":23,"page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":28,"reason":"Of 9 claim findings, 2 were disputed (claim_findings[1] and [2]: the page says Steeves apologized and proposed 'lock staking', but the sources report no apology and call the proposal 'lock-based subnet ownership') and 2 could not be verified (claim_findings[7] and [8], not checked in the review's time budget), giving 44%, which falls in the significant-issues band. The core account holds up: the April 9, 2026 exit, the 'decentralization theatre' quote and the roughly 15% TAO drop are confirmed by Tier 2 sources. The penalty is set at the mild end of the band because the disputed items are wording errors rather than errors in the core allegations, the unverifiable items are already labelled provisional on the page, and the reviewer's confidence was moderate (0.6). No shutdown, exploit or sanction was found, and the one omission (Covenant AI's post-exit plans) is minor. The high-priority gap is the lack of primary sources (Dare's statement, on-chain records for the alleged 37,000 TAO sale).","replaces_fact_checks":{"score_before_fact_checks":38,"undone":2},"reviewer_def_hash":"3839668b232611e5b26db72079d64745f8e57e919b8a379e79b44ba4a52c845b","score_delta":-5,"score_limit":{"applied":-15,"limited":false,"proposed":-15,"rule":"second_opinion_agreed","second":-15},"sequence_num":7,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 9d40684b-73e1-416e-bbd2-0c7c8ce1995c
  8. #8reviewby reviewerreviewer
    2026-11-17 21:41:43Z
    Score: 23 → 23 (no score change)
    The core claims about the April 2026 exit, Steeves' denials, the Tao Papers allegations, the price move and the 37,000 TAO sale are supported by the sources I fetched and are appropriately hedged as allegations. Minor issues are an unsupported attribution of 'lock-based subnet ownership' to the cited Block article, an unitemized per-subnet sale claim, the conflation of a wallet holding with the sale value, and a derived 14x figure. Not all cited sources could be fetched in this pass, and the entity's current status is unknown.
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 470,688,049
    sig
    5auz2Xd6ucwZ…qGAGtBBLexplorer ↗
    hash
    7EgG551QEg31…kZWDG7jLsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1376 B) ▸
    {"actor":"reviewer","artifact_identity":"7a5e97f9e3ed282b2fed262304ca1e52","decided_at":"2026-11-17T21:41:43.179Z","decision":"review","disputed_pct":0,"findings_hash":"BitUTD7gtuk14DaMFF2s1tXKq9tNmTx6hzK6HadWQrSY","investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"750934ecb48272224909b7430fab271676d391380fbc821acbe7ee7e4cac2fa3","new_score":23,"omissions":{"material":0,"total":2},"page_content_hash":"3db5ea6a5f6ef1249561273241e906583cff8186425bf1f945ab75f021084def","page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":23,"reason":"The core claims about the April 2026 exit, Steeves' denials, the Tao Papers allegations, the price move and the 37,000 TAO sale are supported by the sources I fetched and are appropriately hedged as allegations. Minor issues are an unsupported attribution of 'lock-based subnet ownership' to the cited Block article, an unitemized per-subnet sale claim, the conflation of a wallet holding with the sale value, and a derived 14x figure. Not all cited sources could be fetched in this pass, and the entity's current status is unknown.","reviewer_def_hash":"fdb97944d5e6ae9b148ae8c41caf98db055a4c751afd15721cb2e08d11dfd37a","score_delta":0,"sequence_num":8,"subject_status":"unknown","subject_status_contradicts_page":false,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 449ebfa3-be07-48b6-936d-efa326944bf6
  9. #9review approveby judgejudge
    2026-11-17 21:41:43Z
    Score: 23 → 38 (+15)
    Of 8 claim findings, 4 were confirmed and 4 partially supported; none were disputed or unverifiable, so disputed_pct is 0%. The partial findings are minor sourcing issues: claim_findings[2] cites a Block article that does not mention 'lock-based subnet ownership' (other coverage does), claim_findings[4] has no per-subnet breakdown in the source and may conflate a wallet holding with sale value, and claim_findings[6] uses a derived 14x figure. The two omissions are minor and no change of subject status was found. The open high-priority gap (no primary Covenant AI or Dare response located) suggests expansion rather than a penalty, since the page already frames the Tao Papers and sale claims as allegations.
    anchoranchored
    chain
    ●mainnet-betaslot 470,688,057
    sig
    5V25ga8Rdtvk…LXhTnhMsexplorer ↗
    hash
    D1QQBuQ5gTHL…yzVgeA2gsha256 → base58
    verifying row…full verify ↗
    canonical bytes (1421 B) ▸
    {"actor":"judge","artifact_identity":"7a5e97f9e3ed282b2fed262304ca1e52","band_override":null,"decided_at":"2026-11-17T21:41:43.179Z","decision":"review_approve","delist_requested":false,"disputed_pct":0,"investigation_id":"3072ee6d-b912-4d9f-9fab-e87d1acbd2a1","judge_def_hash":"750934ecb48272224909b7430fab271676d391380fbc821acbe7ee7e4cac2fa3","new_score":38,"page_slug":"covenant-ai","prev_score":23,"reason":"Of 8 claim findings, 4 were confirmed and 4 partially supported; none were disputed or unverifiable, so disputed_pct is 0%. The partial findings are minor sourcing issues: claim_findings[2] cites a Block article that does not mention 'lock-based subnet ownership' (other coverage does), claim_findings[4] has no per-subnet breakdown in the source and may conflate a wallet holding with sale value, and claim_findings[6] uses a derived 14x figure. The two omissions are minor and no change of subject status was found. The open high-priority gap (no primary Covenant AI or Dare response located) suggests expansion rather than a penalty, since the page already frames the Tao Papers and sale claims as allegations.","replaces_fact_checks":{"score_before_fact_checks":38,"undone":3},"reviewer_def_hash":"fdb97944d5e6ae9b148ae8c41caf98db055a4c751afd15721cb2e08d11dfd37a","score_delta":15,"sequence_num":9,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}
    Verify offline (run on your own machine)
    python -m src.verify_decision 491bce47-c3d9-4fd5-bc9e-4c3cb0f17ca4
How verification works. The “Row integrity” check above is computed in your browser — your machine recomputes the SHA-256 of the canonical bytes and compares against the stored hash. No avoid.net server can fake that check. The “full verify” link goes one level deeper: your browser fetches the on-chain transaction from a Solana RPC node and confirms the same hash is in the memo. If you don’t want to trust either avoid.net or the public RPC, run the CLI verifier on your own machine — python -m src.verify_decision <event_id>.