Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-08-25T19:22:14.331Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"0f0d20de-6cb0-4351-ac30-7d3384dabfb9","new_score":0,"page_slug":"dean-daghita-cmdss-command-services-and-support","prev_score":4,"reason":"The core narrative of this page -- an alleged $46 million insider crypto theft by John Daghita from U.S. Marshals Service wallets, his arrest in Saint Martin, and a 15-count federal indictment -- is well-corroborated across independent reporting and holds up (15 of 21 claims fully confirmed). Two problems keep this from a clean approval. First, claim_findings[17] found that the claim about CMDSS's website and social accounts going offline is cited to two sources that do not actually contain that information, even though the underlying fact appears true elsewhere -- a citation-accuracy defect that needs correction on the page. Second, and more important given the seriousness of the allegations, a high-priority coverage gap notes that the page omits a detail available in its own cited Yahoo Finance source: that CMDSS was asked for comment and did not respond. Leaving that out understates fairness to Dean Daghita, who has not been charged. A minor age discrepancy (21 vs. 22) was also found. Three additional findings marked 'unverifiable' reflect paywalled or inaccessible sources rather than actual factual problems, and the reviewer confirmed this page does not repeat a dating error found on a related sibling page, instead relying on better-sourced, contemporaneous reporting for that date. Taken together, this warrants revision -- fixing the mis-cited claim and adding the missing fairness detail -- but not removal or heavier sanction.","score_delta":-12,"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}