Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-08-27T10:41:38.833Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"eb936eda-2c70-449f-8e13-283e5982728e","new_score":33,"page_slug":"united-stables-u","prev_score":48,"reason":"Independent verification confirmed most of the page's claims (22 of 28), including the entity structure, licensing self-disclosures, most exchange listings, the Chainlink partnership, and both documented peg-pressure events, so this is not a page that broadly falls apart. But the single most important fact for a stablecoin -- what backs the token -- is compromised: claim_findings[12] states a precise reserve figure for June 18, 2026 that its own cited article directly contradicts, since that article explicitly says no public reserve data is known. That is compounded by two partially-supported findings on the same theme: claim_findings[16] shows the page's own cited CoinGecko data records a 3.18% peg deviation shortly after launch that the page omits while claiming a tight 0.05% band, and claim_findings[10] shows the page names specific reserve assets with more certainty than the actual Terms and Conditions, which leaves composition to the issuer's sole discretion. A separate disputed listing claim, claim_findings[21] (Coinbase), also could not be corroborated and appears likely wrong. The review's own coverage_gaps[0], rated high priority, calls for independent on-chain Proof-of-Reserve verification for exactly this reason. Raw disputed_pct (7.1%) sits in the approve range, but the concentration of defects around the page's central solvency claim, plus the high-priority gap tied to it, is enough to require revision rather than a clean pass; it does not, however, rise to the volume or reviewer-confidence level needed for a harsher outcome, given the reviewer's moderate-to-good confidence (0.72) and the fact that most claims held up under direct source checks.","score_delta":-15,"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}