Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-08-25T03:23:53.528Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"04dda7b6-f794-4b66-935c-a543b8ab3006","new_score":0,"page_slug":"indonesia-pig-butchering-syndicate-live-model-operation-2025-2026","prev_score":2,"reason":"Of the 32 claims the reviewer actually checked, 22 were confirmed, 6 partially supported, 2 disputed, and 2 flagged as unverifiable-but-reasonable, putting the disputed rate at 12.5% (2/32) rather than the review's misstated 14%. That still falls in the minor-issues band, but two corrections are needed before this qualifies as a clean pass. claim_findings[7] flags an incorrect romanization of the Chinese term for the scheme ('sholai zhu pan' instead of 'sha zhu pan') -- a cosmetic error. More substantively, claim_findings[22] shows the page overstates a background statistic, attributing all 3,703 Foreign Ministry-logged overseas job-scam cases to human trafficking when independent reporting indicates only about 40% (roughly 1,480) were classified as trafficking; on a page dealing with trafficking and coercion, a roughly 2.5x overstatement of that figure needs correcting even though it sits in contextual background material, not the core allegations against the named syndicate or suspects. Separately, claim_findings[24] and [31] show the page's US$46.9M USDT freeze is misdated to August 2025 in both a section and the timeline -- that is the disclosure date, not the June 2024 freeze date -- which should be fixed for timeline accuracy. Finally, coverage_gaps[0] is rated high priority: no source addresses whether any of the 39 domestic suspects have raised a coercion or trafficking defense, which the page should address explicitly given it already distinguishes the paid domestic operation from the separately documented trafficked-abroad population. None of this touches the page's core allegations -- arrest count, victim count, dollar losses, named suspect Febiola Elizabeth's alleged role, and the criminal charges -- which the reviewer found solidly corroborated across independent tier-1/2 sources despite some cited URLs being bot-blocked.","score_delta":-10,"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}