Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-08-25T22:39:19.882Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"6cd96f54-27d5-462b-845c-2f5abd046709","new_score":0,"page_slug":"jiang-wen-jie","prev_score":2,"reason":"Of 22 fact-checked claims, 17 were confirmed, 1 was disputed, and 2 were unverifiable, putting disputed_pct at 13.6% (1 partially_supported and 1 stale finding are correctly excluded from that ratio per the review methodology). That places the page in the minor-issues band, but two of the flagged items carry more weight than a bare percentage suggests. claim_findings[12] found that the Protos article cited to support the Shunda Park compound-operations section actually describes a different, much larger compound (KK Park) and never mentions Shunda Park -- a real citation defect, even though the underlying prose about Shunda Park is independently corroborated elsewhere. claim_findings[3] found the page states flatly that Jiang 'remains in Thai custody' as of August 2026, but the reviewer could only verify custody through roughly April-May 2026; no source was found confirming or contradicting his status since, so that sentence is more confident than the evidence supports for a living, unconvicted individual. Separately, claim_findings[18] flags that the page's '$64 billion annual profit' figure is a 2023-vintage estimate now understated against a February 2026 UN estimate ($88-114 billion) that predates the page's own August 2026 sourcing, so a more current figure was reasonably available. On the identity side, the reviewer found the page adequately pins Jiang Wen Jie to this specific case (alias 'Jiang Nan,' named co-defendant, specific compound, charge date) despite unrelated namesakes existing, which mitigates the main harm risk for a page naming a charged-but-unconvicted person. None of the five coverage gaps were flagged high priority, and reviewer confidence (0.72) is moderate rather than low, so no additional band movement is warranted, but the currency and citation issues justify a delta toward the firmer end of the minor-issues range rather than the floor.","score_delta":-12,"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}