Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-08-25T17:15:43.868Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"56994de0-caa9-4f3b-a96b-45f2684a5ad6","new_score":0,"page_slug":"nicolo-nourafchan-robert-yadgarov-sec-doj-insider-trading-ring","prev_score":2,"reason":"The page's factual scaffolding — defendant rosters across both indictments and the SEC complaint, every charge-to-defendant assignment, six independently checked dollar figures, the five foreign regulators, and the 20-year statutory maxima — was verified word-for-word against the primary DOJ indictments and SEC complaint (claim_findings[0,3,4,7-15,18-21,26-28]), giving a disputed_pct of 20.7% (4 disputed + 2 unverifiable of 29 claims), which sits in the revise band. But one of the four disputed claims carries outsized weight: the page states in three places (M&A Deals section, timeline, and Criminal Charges section) that Nourafchan's obstruction of justice counts arise from accessing iRobot deal files while on leave in 2022, when the indictment's actual obstruction counts concern unrelated July 2025 conduct — instructing a co-conspirator to lie to investigators and destroying phone evidence (claim_findings[17]). This is the reviewer's sole high-priority coverage gap and misdescribes, for a named individual facing real criminal prosecution, both what he is charged with and what he isn't. Three additional issues compound the concern: the page attributes a 2014 scheme start date to both the SEC and DOJ when the SEC's own complaint defines its period as 2018-2024, inflating apparent exposure (claim_findings[5]); it says Gershowitz 'received' a $30,000 kickback when the complaint states he was owed that amount but actually received less (claim_findings[16]); and it asserts the SEC will seek industry bars, a remedy not found anywhere in the complaint's prayer for relief (claim_findings[23]). Given the reviewer's high confidence (0.82) and the direct, document-verified nature of these findings, the correction burden is real even though it does not undermine the page's core narrative.","score_delta":-15,"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}