Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-08-25T22:49:25.087Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"a531e342-f813-4cf2-ad17-392497d9e60f","new_score":0,"page_slug":"mica-post-deadline-impersonation-scam-cluster-esma-amf-warning-august-2026","prev_score":0,"reason":"The reviewer confirmed 23 of 26 claims outright, with zero disputed or unverifiable claims and no link rot on any citation; the page's core narrative — the MiCA transitional-period expiry, ESMA's and AMF's confirmed impersonation cases, and Belgium's FSMA blacklist of six named unauthorized entities — is well corroborated by primary regulatory sources. However, the disputed-claim count does not capture two accuracy problems worth correcting. First, claim_findings[9] shows the page's top-level summary states that ESMA, France's AMF, the Dutch AFM, and Belgium's FSMA jointly 'documented a significant surge in impersonation scams,' when only ESMA and AMF are actually documented as having been impersonated; AFM issued a general caution and FSMA's action targeted unauthorized providers, not impersonation of FSMA itself. Notably, the page's own Attribution section already draws this distinction correctly — only the summary overstates it. Second, claim_findings[10] found no source naming Coinbase, Kraken, or OKX as impersonation targets; the underlying reporting names them only as examples of licensed, MiCA-authorized exchanges. Stating specific real companies were targeted, without a source, is a sourcing lapse on a platform whose core value proposition is sourced evidence, even though the framing itself does not accuse them of wrongdoing. A third partially-supported item (claim_findings[17], an unverified 2020 loss-figure comparison) is minor and does not affect the page's core claims. None of this rises to a disputed core allegation, and reviewer confidence was reasonably high (0.82) with no critical citation showing link rot or staleness, so the issues call for a correction pass rather than a significant-issues label or investigation status change.","score_delta":-6,"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}