Verify a decision

{"actor":"judge","decided_at":"2026-06-09T22:40:16.237Z","decision":"review_revise","investigation_id":"e198003e-9540-4950-a4cc-3868bcd92ce3","new_score":57,"page_slug":"gnosis-pay-zodiac-delay-module-exploit","prev_score":62,"reason":"The page is broadly accurate and well-sourced: 18 of 22 claims were independently confirmed, zero claims were disputed by any source, and all core facts — exploit date, affected module versions, $265,000 loss estimate, 41-Safe count, on-chain fund movement, Köppelmann reimbursement pledge, and 99% service restoration — hold up. Two link-rot findings (claim_findings[21] and claim_findings[22]) reflect HTTP 403 paywall restrictions on The Block and The Defiant, not dead links; the underlying claims are confirmed by independent sources. One partially-supported finding (claim_findings[15]) notes that the page overstates balance restoration as completed when sources describe it as a pledge in progress at time of reporting. A high-priority coverage gap flags that the vulnerability was silently patched in the zodiac-core repository on February 27, 2026, months before the exploit, while production instances remained on the legacy vulnerable package — material context for responsibility assessment that is absent from the page. A light revision incorporating that disclosure timeline context and softening the balance-restoration language would bring the page to full accuracy.","score_delta":-5,"sequence_num":3,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}