Verify a decision

{"actor":"reviewer","decided_at":"2026-06-14T23:16:11.509Z","decision":"review","investigation_id":"3b842216-f507-4ebb-bde7-38c82dbe8ff8","new_score":42,"page_slug":"scroll","prev_score":42,"reason":"Blue-chip calibration review (Prompt A). Verdict: over-penalized. Page content is treated as accurate; the trust_score band is miscalibrated. Scroll is a legitimate, well-funded Ethereum Layer 2 zkEVM operated by credentialed founders (Sandy Peng, Ye Zhang, Haichen Shen), backed by Polychain Capital and Bain Capital Crypto, that raised $83M in documented VC rounds. None of the incidents documented on the page constitute fraud by Scroll itself: the gas fee overcharge ($50K excess across 139K transactions) was a manual configuration error, not intentional misappropriation; the SCR airdrop whale concentration, while legitimately criticized, is a governance/design decision within normal industry parameters for L2 token launches; the Security Council dissolution was a documented cost-cutting response to ecosystem outflows. The page's WARNING band (20–49) requires elevated fraud or loss risk or unresolved severe incident — none of these incidents meet that threshold individually or collectively. Critically, the page omits Scroll's April 2025 Euclid upgrade, which made it the first ZK-rollup to achieve Stage 1 decentralization (confirmed by CoinDesk), and it misdescribes the gas oracle multiplier as '160x increase' when the actual cumulative increase was 1,280x (160x was the corrective reduction). The correct band is CAUTIONARY (50–69): a legitimate protocol with material operational caveats — declining TVL, governance centralization concerns, and a documented fee configuration error — but no fraud or unresolved severe incident. A score of 58 reflects the documented operational and governance concerns without penalizing mere market-cycle TVL contraction.","score_delta":0,"sequence_num":2,"submission_content_hash":null,"submission_id":null,"submission_kind":null,"submission_valence":null,"v":1}